Same Momentum, Same Energy Lost? Swapped Carts FRQ
Pause here: To build true exam stamina, attempt these questions on your own before checking the model answers.
FRQ: Kinetic Energy Transformed in a Perfectly Inelastic Collision — Same Momentum, Swapped Carts
Assessments aligned to 2026 AP Physics 1 standards
Qualitative/Quantitative Translation (QQT) | CHALLENGE | 8 points | 20 min
▤ Scenario
Cart X has mass m and Cart Y has mass 3m. The carts are used in two trials on a straight, level track, as shown in Figure 1. Velcro pads on the carts make them stick together when they collide.
In Trial 1, Cart X is launched toward Cart Y, which is at rest. In Trial 2, Cart Y is launched toward Cart X, which is at rest. In each trial, the launched cart has momentum of the same magnitude p immediately before the collision.
Figure 1. The two trials immediately before the collision. The launched cart has momentum p in each trial.
Friction between the carts and the track and air resistance are negligible, and the wheels of the carts have negligible mass. Let ΔK_1 and ΔK_2 represent the decrease in the total kinetic energy of the two-cart system during the collision in Trial 1 and in Trial 2, respectively.
✎ Free Response Questions
Part A
Indicate whether ΔK_2 is greater than, less than, or equal to ΔK_1 by writing one of the following.
• ΔK_2 > ΔK_1
• ΔK_2 < ΔK_1
• ΔK_2 = ΔK_1
Justify your answer using qualitative reasoning beyond referencing equations.
Part B
Starting with conservation of momentum, derive an expression for the decrease ΔK in the total kinetic energy of a two-cart system when a cart of mass m_1, which has momentum p immediately before the collision, collides with and sticks to a cart of mass m_2 that is at rest. Express your final answer in terms of p, m_1, m_2, and physical constants, as appropriate. Begin your derivation by writing the fundamental physics principle or an equation from the reference information.
Part C
Justify how your derived equation in part B is or is not consistent with your reasoning in part A.
❖ Answer Key & Scoring Guide
▸ earns credit ⚠︎ common error, partial credit ✗ common error, no credit
Points are independent and there are no deductions. ▸ criteria follow College Board's published scoring standard; ⚠︎ and ✗ lines are TheScienceCube teaching commentary, not College Board rubric.
Part A — Model Answer
ΔK_2 < ΔK_1.
After the collision the two trials are identical. The system has the same momentum p and the same total mass in each trial, so the stuck-together carts move at the same velocity and have the same kinetic energy.
Before the collision the trials differ. To have the same momentum as Cart Y, the lighter Cart X must move three times as fast. Kinetic energy grows with the square of the speed but only in proportion to the mass, so the fast, light Cart X in Trial 1 has more kinetic energy than the slow, heavy Cart Y in Trial 2. Trial 1 starts with more kinetic energy and ends with the same amount, so more kinetic energy is transformed in Trial 1.
Scoring (3 points):
▸ A1 — 1 point: For selecting ΔK_2 < ΔK_1 with an attempt at a relevant justification.
▸ A2 — 1 point: For indicating that the kinetic energy of the system after the collision is the same in both trials, because the momentum of the system and its total mass are the same.
▸ A3 — 1 point: For indicating, with valid reasoning, that the kinetic energy before the collision is greater in Trial 1 (for example, for the same momentum the less massive cart moves faster, and the same momentum at a greater speed means more kinetic energy).
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): Selects “equal”, reasoning correctly that the trials end with the same momentum and total mass and so the same kinetic energy, but assuming that they also begin with the same kinetic energy because they begin with the same momentum. Point A2 is earned; A1 and A3 are not — earns 1 of 3 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): Selects “greater than”, reasoning that the more massive cart hits harder and so wastes more energy, with no comparison of the kinetic energies before or after the collision.
Part B — Model Answer
The net external force on the two-cart system is zero, so the momentum of the system immediately after the collision equals the momentum p of the moving cart immediately before it. Let v_1 be the speed of the moving cart before the collision and v_f the speed of the carts after it.
p = m_1 v_1 = (m_1 + m_2) v_f so v_1 = p/m_1 and v_f = p/(m_1 + m_2)
ΔK = K_i − K_f = ½ m_1 v_1² − ½ (m_1 + m_2) v_f²
ΔK = p²/(2m_1) − p²/[2(m_1 + m_2)]
ΔK = p² m_2 / [2 m_1 (m_1 + m_2)]
Scoring (3 points):
▸ B1 — 1 point: For writing an equation that expresses conservation of momentum for the collision, such as p = (m_1 + m_2) v_f.
▸ B2 — 1 point: For writing the decrease as the kinetic energy before the collision minus the kinetic energy after it, with each kinetic energy written correctly for the mass that is moving.
▸ B3 — 1 point: For a correct final expression in terms of p, m_1 and m_2: ΔK = p² m_2 / [2 m_1 (m_1 + m_2)], or the equivalent p²/(2m_1) − p²/[2(m_1 + m_2)].
Scoring Note: A correct, isolated, final expression for ΔK earns points B2 and B3.
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): Completes a correct derivation but leaves the answer in terms of the speed v_1, for example ΔK = ½ m_1 v_1² m_2/(m_1 + m_2), without eliminating v_1 in favor of p. Points B1 and B2 are earned; B3 is not — earns 2 of 3 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): Finds the final speed by setting the kinetic energy before the collision equal to the kinetic energy after it, which makes ΔK zero. No momentum equation is written, and kinetic energy is not constant when the carts stick together.
Part C — Model Answer
In both trials p is the same and m_1 + m_2 = 4m is the same, so the equation says that ΔK is proportional to m_2/m_1: the mass of the cart at rest divided by the mass of the cart that is launched.
Trial 1 (m_1 = m, m_2 = 3m): ΔK_1 = p²(3m) / [2(m)(4m)] = 3p²/(8m)
Trial 2 (m_1 = 3m, m_2 = m): ΔK_2 = p²(m) / [2(3m)(4m)] = p²/(24m)
The equation gives ΔK_2 < ΔK_1, which is consistent with part A. Launching the lighter cart puts m_1 small in the denominator, which is the algebraic form of “the lighter cart needs more kinetic energy to carry the same momentum.”
Scoring (2 points):
▸ C1 — 1 point: For using the functional dependence of the derived equation on the masses to compare the two trials: with p and m_1 + m_2 the same, ΔK is larger when the launched cart is the less massive one (or evaluating ΔK for each trial).
▸ C2 — 1 point: For a statement that the equation is, or is not, consistent with the reasoning in part A, in agreement with the responses given in parts A and B.
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): States that the equation is consistent with part A but only restates the part A answer, without referring to how ΔK depends on m_1 or m_2 in the equation. Point C2 is earned; C1 is not — earns 1 of 2 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): Notes only that p is the same in both trials, concludes that the equation predicts equal decreases, and makes no statement about consistency with part A.


0 comments