Does a Heavier Cart Gain More Momentum? Push Zone FRQ
Pause here: To build true exam stamina, attempt these questions on your own before checking the model answers.
FRQ: Change in Momentum from a Constant Force — The Push Zone
Assessments aligned to 2026 AP Physics 1 standards
Qualitative/Quantitative Translation (QQT) | CHALLENGE | 8 points | 20 min
▤ Scenario
In a loading bay, a push zone of length d is marked on the level floor between a start line and a finish line, as shown in Figure 1. A worker pushes a cart through the zone with a horizontal force of constant magnitude F_0, read from a force gauge on the handle. The cart starts from rest at the start line, and the worker stops pushing as the cart crosses the finish line.
Figure 1. The cart is pushed with a constant force F_0 through a zone of length d.
In trial 1 the cart is empty and has mass m. In trial 2 the same cart is loaded and has total mass 4m. The worker pushes with the same force F_0 in both trials. The magnitude of the cart’s momentum as it crosses the finish line is p_E in trial 1 (empty) and p_L in trial 2 (loaded).
Friction and air resistance are negligible. All motion is along the x-axis. Use the floor as the reference frame.
✎ Free Response Questions
Part A
Indicate whether p_L is greater than, less than, or equal to p_E by writing one of the following.
• p_L > p_E
• p_L < p_E
• p_L = p_E
Justify your answer using qualitative reasoning beyond referencing equations.
Part B
Starting with Newton’s second law, derive an expression for the magnitude p of the momentum of a cart of total mass M as it crosses the finish line. Express your final answer in terms of F_0, d, M, and physical constants, as appropriate. Begin your derivation by writing the fundamental physics principle or an equation from the reference information.
Part C
Justify how your derived equation in part B is or is not consistent with your reasoning in part A.
❖ Answer Key & Scoring Guide
▸ earns credit ⚠︎ common error, partial credit ✗ common error, no credit
Points are independent and there are no deductions. ▸ criteria follow College Board’s published scoring standard; ⚠︎ and ✗ lines are TheScienceCube teaching commentary, not College Board rubric.
Part A — Model Answer
p_L > p_E
The same force acts on both carts, but the loaded cart has four times the mass, so its acceleration is smaller and it takes longer to cover the same distance d. The net force on an object is the rate at which its momentum changes, so the same force acting for a longer time produces a larger change in momentum. Both carts start with zero momentum, so the loaded cart crosses the finish line with more.
A given force builds momentum in proportion to the time for which it acts, not the distance it covers. The loaded cart is slower at the finish line, but its larger mass more than makes up for that.
Scoring (3 points):
▸ A1 — 1 point: For indicating that the loaded cart has the smaller acceleration and therefore spends a longer time in the push zone.
▸ A2 — 1 point: For relating the change in momentum to the force and the time for which it acts: the same force acting for a longer time produces a larger change in momentum.
▸ A3 — 1 point: For selecting p_L > p_E, with an attempt at a relevant justification.
Scoring Note: Any correct line of reasoning earns A1 and A2. For example: the same force over the same distance gives both carts the same kinetic energy (A1), and of two objects with equal kinetic energy the more massive, slower one has the greater momentum (A2).
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): selects p_L > p_E only because the loaded cart “has more mass”, without accounting for its lower speed — earns A3 only; 1 of 3 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): selects p_L = p_E because “the same force gives the same change in momentum” — that is true only when the forces act for the same time, and here they act over the same distance; earns no points.
Part B — Model Answer
Newton’s second law for a cart of mass M, with F_0 as the net force:
F_0 = M a, so a = F_0 / M
The cart starts from rest and has constant acceleration over the distance d, so the time t it spends in the zone follows from
d = ½ a t², so t = √(2d / a) = √(2dM / F_0)
The net force equals the rate of change of momentum, and the momentum starts at zero:
F_0 = Δp / Δt = p / t, so p = F_0 t = F_0 √(2dM / F_0)
p = √(2 M F_0 d)
The route through the final speed gives the same result: v² = 2ad gives v = √(2F_0 d/M), and then p = Mv = √(2 M F_0 d).
Scoring (3 points):
▸ B1 — 1 point: For starting from Newton’s second law for the cart, F_0 = Ma or F_0 = Δp/Δt.
▸ B2 — 1 point: For a correct constant-acceleration relationship that links the distance d to the time in the zone or to the final speed, d = ½at² or v² = 2ad.
▸ B3 — 1 point: For the correct final expression, p = √(2 M F_0 d).
Scoring Note: A correct, isolated, final expression for p earns points B2 and B3.
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): correctly derives the final speed, v = √(2F_0 d/M), and gives that as the answer without multiplying by M — earns B1 and B2; 2 of 3 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): writes p = F_0 d with no statement of Newton’s second law — force multiplied by distance is not a change in momentum, and its unit is not kg·m/s; earns no points.
Part C — Model Answer
The derived equation, p = √(2 M F_0 d), shows that for the same force F_0 and the same distance d the momentum at the finish line increases with the mass of the cart: it is proportional to √M. With four times the mass, the loaded cart has √4 = 2 times the momentum of the empty cart.
This is consistent with the reasoning in part A, where the more massive cart spends longer in the zone under the same force and so gains more momentum. The equation also says by how much: twice, not four times, because the loaded cart is in the zone only twice as long.
Scoring (2 points):
▸ C1 — 1 point: For identifying how the mass appears in the equation derived in part B: for the same F_0 and d, p increases as M increases (p is proportional to √M).
▸ C2 — 1 point: For a statement that this dependence on mass is, or is not, consistent with the reasoning given in part A, with a reason that refers to that reasoning.
Scoring Note: These points are for the consistency argument, judged against the student’s own parts A and B. A student who selected p_L = p_E in part A and derived p = √(2 M F_0 d) in part B earns both points by explaining that the two are not consistent.
⚠︎ Common error (partial credit): states that the equation gives a larger momentum for the larger mass but does not refer back to part A — earns C1 only; 1 of 2 points.
✗ Common error (no credit): writes only “they are consistent” (or “not consistent”) with no reference to how M appears in the equation; earns no points.


0 comments