Nature does not fix the zero. You choose the level — then stay with it for the whole problem.
A negative U only means the parcel is below your level. Nothing is missing.
U changes with your choice. ΔU does not — and only ΔU affects the physics.
In short: You can place U = 0 at any level, but you must keep that choice for the whole problem. Changing the zero changes every value of U, yet the change ΔU between two points stays the same. Only ΔU affects the physics.
1. What does a negative U mean? It only means the object is below the level you chose as zero. Nothing is missing.
2. Which zero level is best? Any works. Pick the one that makes the problem simplest, often the lowest point, so U is never negative.
3. Why does ΔU not depend on the zero? Because ΔU = mgΔy is a difference of two heights measured from the same zero, so the reference cancels.
Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?