Should You Count Gravity as Work or as Potential Energy?

Teachers: assign this simulation to your class in one click. Free for classroom use. Share to Google Classroom
Conservation of Mechanical Energy: One Ride, Two Systems

Conservation of Mechanical Energy: One Ride, Two Systems

Release the car, then switch the system while it rides. Watch which bars appear.
PHYSICS INSIGHTS

The car alone can only have kinetic energy. Gravity is then an outside force that does work W on it.

Put the Earth inside the system and the same energy is counted as a change in U, with no work term.

One or the other, never both: the car's K is the same in both pictures.

Simulation by The Science Cube — https://www.thesciencecube.com/

Should You Count Gravity as Work or as Potential Energy?

In short: It depends on the system you choose. For the car alone, gravity is an outside force that does work W on it, and only kinetic energy changes. For the car + Earth system, the same energy is a change in U with no work term. Use one picture or the other, never both.

Three common doubts

1. Does the car's kinetic energy depend on the system I choose? No. The car's K is identical in both pictures. Only how you account for the energy change differs.

2. Why can't I use both work and ΔU for gravity? That would count the same energy twice. Gravity's work on the car equals −ΔU of the car–Earth system, so pick one.

3. When is the car + Earth system the easier choice? When only gravity and forces that do no work act, since then K + U is conserved and you skip computing the work.

Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?


Equations & Traps: the AP Physics 1 equation deck. See Equations & Traps

AP Physics 1 Mind Maps: every topic on one page. See the Mind Maps

Complete and Continue