Should You Count Gravity as Work or as Potential Energy?
Conservation of Mechanical Energy: One Ride, Two Systems
The car alone can only have kinetic energy. Gravity is then an outside force that does work W on it.
Put the Earth inside the system and the same energy is counted as a change in U, with no work term.
One or the other, never both: the car's K is the same in both pictures.
Should You Count Gravity as Work or as Potential Energy?
In short: It depends on the system you choose. For the car alone, gravity is an outside force that does work W on it, and only kinetic energy changes. For the car + Earth system, the same energy is a change in U with no work term. Use one picture or the other, never both.
Three common doubts
1. Does the car's kinetic energy depend on the system I choose? No. The car's K is identical in both pictures. Only how you account for the energy change differs.
2. Why can't I use both work and ΔU for gravity? That would count the same energy twice. Gravity's work on the car equals −ΔU of the car–Earth system, so pick one.
3. When is the car + Earth system the easier choice? When only gravity and forces that do no work act, since then K + U is conserved and you skip computing the work.
Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?
- Learn it step by step: Explore the AP Physics 1 course

